We Tried 7 Boxed Yellow Cake Mixes and This Was the Best
A battle of the batters.
Despite how many stories we may publish about it, the MyRecipes staff remains divided on cake. Half of us aren’t fans whatsoever, while the other half are loyal diehards. That said, whether you love it or hate it, you're eventually probably going to have to bake one. But if you're not looking to make it entirely from-scratch, which box from the grocery store should you buy? We baked seven boxed yellow cakes to determine which could truly be called the best.
Meet the Mixes
This was a boxed mix battle, so obviously we had to include the giants: Betty Crocker, Duncan Hines, and Pillsbury. As you can see by their boxes, those three brands clearly prioritize moisture. Next, we picked up a box of Jiffy Golden Yellow Cake Mix, which is known for its ease and affordability.
On the non-GMO front, we opted for Immaculate’s Yellow Cake Scratch Mix, which I found at Whole Foods. I also picked up a box of King Arthur’s gluten-free mix, both out of a desire for inclusivity and respect for the brand. We also made Simple Mills’ keto-friendly Vanilla Almond Flour Mix, whose six-ingredient batter contains no dairy, soy, gluten, or gum whatsoever. Everyone deserves cake, no matter what kind of allergies they have.
Not Our Favorites, But Still Cake
Most Surprising: Simple Mills Gluten Free Vanilla Cake Almond Flour Mix
“Looks like banana bread, tastes like spice cake.”
This mix is made from almond flour and requires you to add your own vanilla, so I had doubts from the start. As you can see from the box, this cake definitely isn’t yellow, which, paired with the slightly dry texture and bland taste, deterred testers. (Did I make a goof at the store? Maybe, but yellow cake is vanilla cake powered by egg yolks, so I gave myself a pass. Plus, I wanted more than one gluten-free option.)
Most Likely to Feel Like You Made It Yourself: Immaculate Yellow Cake Scratch Mix
“A little too tough and dry.”
I’ll be honest, I tasted a bit of this batter, and it gave me high expectations. Extra ingredients were required since it’s a “from scratch” mix, and they all came together in the bowl like a dream. Once it was baked and ready to eat, however, this cake disappointed. It was dry (one tester asked if we left it in the oven too long; rest assured, we did not) and had a minimally sweet flavor that made it taste more like bread than cake.
Easiest: Jiffy Golden Yellow Cake Mix
“Decent flavor but dry.”
Jiffy is primarily associated with cornbread, but they also sell an all-purpose baking mix, a few varieties of muffin mixes, and yes, yellow cake mix. Our neighborhood Piggly Wiggly had these going for 84 cents, but it should be noted that there’s only enough product to make one 8-inch cake layer. Preparation is pretty straightforward, with the only additional ingredients being one egg and half a cup of cold water. The finished product’s texture landed somewhere between a white cake and a pancake, with that same subtly sweet flavor found in Jiffy’s cornbread.
Best Texture, Runner-Up: Duncan Hines Classic Yellow Deliciously Moist Cake Mix
“Light and fluffy, nicely sweet.”
While this mix wasn’t disliked, compared to the other brands it was second tier. The texture was fluffy and moist, much like the favorite cake mix of the bunch, but some tasters thought this cake was more like a quickbread, or just weren’t fans of the taste.
Mixes that Take the Cake
Most Durable: Pillsbury Moist Supreme Yellow Cake Mix
“Buttery, rich, and addictive.”
The Pillsbury cake didn’t get quite as many favorites as the Betty Crocker or King Arthur, but there was an area where it surpassed every other mix on the table: structure. We cut each cake into bite-size pieces both to ease the tasting process and test how they’d react to a knife. Pillsbury is the only mix that didn’t crumble, and not a single piece of rogue cake stuck to our knives after applying the frosting. If you’re looking to build a cake with several layers or decorate, this is it.
Best Gluten-Free: King Arthur Gluten Free Yellow Cake Mix
“Very moist and tender, but not fluffy.”
King Arthur’s cake was super moistand had a nice, tamagoyaki-like denseness. Maybe it’s because of the ingredients like rice flour, tapioca starch, cane sugar, and potato starch, but nobody could tell this cake was gluten-free. The dense, satisfying crumb of this cake is likely a product of the additionally ingredients required to make it: milk rather than water, four eggs, and softened butter rather than oil. (By the way, this was definitely the best-tasting raw batter.) This cake is mind-blowingly delicious, but it tastes and feels more like white or angel food cake, so it can’t technically take the “Best Yellow Cake” title.
Best Overall: Betty Crocker Super Moist Yellow Cake Mix
“Tasty but not too strong. 5 out of 5.”
Betty Crocker’s got everything you could want in a classic yellow cake: moisture, a texture that’s both spongy and fluffy, and a buttery, sweet-but-not-too-sweet flavor. Its airness makes additional bites that much harder to resist. Another advantage Betty Crocker’s mix had was that it didn’t look as artificially yellow as some of its competitors. While this cake did crumble under the frosting, it tastes so good that you won’t care.