I liked this soup. Was too lazy to do the meatballs when I decided to fix it (yeah, that lazy) but will remake today with meatballs. I think my mother would enjoy this, so will take her some. I agree with another poster...very comforting. And as is typically the case...I keep adding spices until I get it to my taste instead of the recommended...some more than others.
I won't add red pepper flakes this time around, but might add a little hot Italian sausage to savor it up even more. And didn't use quinoa, but used acini de pepe pasta instead.
My family liked this soup -- very kid-friendly. It's not going to shoot up to the top of our favorites list, but I'd make it again on a cold winter evening. It's comforting and healthy.
We really liked this soup, used regular Kale , could not find the other in the store. I also added a teaspoon of Italian seasonings to the broth. We thought it had lots of flavoring. It did take a little longer to simmer then what the recipe said.Served with bread I made from my bread machine. I will certainly make this again. This soup would be very good to make for a luncheon plus it's a very healthy soup. It's also different because it does not have beans or bacon usually seen in recipes with Kale.
Best soup I've made in a long time. Even the kids loved it. The only thing I did differently was add all the cheese to the meatballs and added extra garlic to the broth. This will be one of our regular soups from now on.
This was delicious. I followed the recipe almost as written and got great results. I chose lean but not super lean ground turkey (antibiotic free, not the jennie o brand) that I got at publix and it wasn't dry. I accidentally added a little more of the fresh herbs than was required to the meatballs. Oops. I also added a splash of white wine to deglaze the pan between the meatballs and the shallots and celery step. I used a high quality organic chicken broth (imagine brand I think) and it was great. I used regular organic kale because that was all I could find. It was great. Even my picky husband enjoyed it.
I made this soup yesterday for a weekend lunch and it was very tasty, but I am only giving the soup 2 stars because I had to make a lot of changes to get the soup in any form of edible. 1) I used roasted garlic flavored quinoa (quick cooking) in the meatballs and forgot to add the egg; didn't have a problem with meatballs staying intact; 2) I added 2 tsp each of garlic powder, onion powder, smoked paprika and italian seasoning to the meatballs (ditto on seasoning and additions to the soup base); 3) Used only 3 cups no salt added stock & 1 cup hot water for broth. Overall, this soup was filling and we enjoyed the textures & flavor profiles, but only after all the additions and changes I made to this one to have some robust flavors. I think the main ingredient that let our soup be delicious was the roasted garlic quinoa I used. Otherwise, this soup would have been bland, bland, bland. It has potential, but be sure to have seasoning on hand to spice it up quickly. Enjoy!
This was just not a good recipe. I thought it would be like Italian wedding soup but it lacked flavor and depth.
I really wanted this recipe to work, turkey, kale, chicken stock, it sounds and looks delicious. After much work though, the family all decided it was really pretty bland. Kids said they would rather not eat again.
We loved this recipe! I think the trick is to use pre-seasoned Jennie-O turkey (the Italian version). Our meatballs were super tasty. I also used 6 cups of chicken stock. When I got to the end of dishing out 6 servings it became clear we needed just a bit more stock, so I added a cup into the mix and that worked out great. I also did a full teaspoon of red pepper flakes which gave it just the right amount of kick. We will definitely be making this again!
I made a double batch and froze individual servings to take to work. So delicious and filling! Be sure to use chicken stock, not broth, for maximum flavor. Also, don't use frozen kale. Use fresh. The baby kale from Costco worked great!
Based on the mixed reviews, I wasn't sure we'd like this. To our surprise, we enjoyed it a lot. I added the minced onions to the meatballs (ooops), used egg beaters instead of eggs (I almost always do) and made the quinoa with chicken stock. I guess my quinoa was dry because I had no trouble with the meatballs staying together but I used 93/7 turkey breast blend. I also eliminated the olive oil from the recipe and used a healthy splash of chicken broth to deglaze the pan before sautéing the vegetables. The broth was kind of bland at first taste, so I added a healthy sprinkle of poultry seasoning. However after allowing the soup to cool a bit, the flavor was spot on. We will have again. I think for flavor, you really need to use a good chicken broth/stock. We will definitely have again.
Agree with alphabetizing in that this looked so good but was rather underwhelming and time consuming to make.
For all the work that goes into this, it's totally underwhelming. Pretty bland and if you cook quinoa like it's SUPPOSED to be cooked, it's not really a great binder for the meatballs--my boyfriend had trouble getting them to stick together, and the meatballs just kept getting bigger as a result of trying to mush them together. Would need to overcook the quinoa a little to dry it out some more for a better meatball I think. You lose a lot of the fresh basil taste in the cooking, and the broth needs more seasoning. It's just really kind of boring and way too much work for the results we got. Big bummer, because it SOUNDED so good in theory, and smelled great during prep. Will not make again. Going to freeze the rest for emergency days, because we don't feel like eating anymore this week but it was too expensive/time consuming to throw out.
This soup was very tasty, I would make it again.
I really wanted to like this recipe, but it was very disappointing. I used 99% fat free turkey, and the meatballs were too large and very dry. The broth was not very tasty either. If I were to try this again, I would use regular ground turkey, and make the meatballs bite-size and barely brown them before adding to soup.