Oxmoor House
Makes 2 dozen

If you’re a peanut butter fan, these cookies won’t last long. You’ll enjoy every last crumb! Don’t forget to serve them with a tall, cold glass of milk.

How to Make It

Combine all ingredients; mix well. Roll dough into one-inch balls and place on an ungreased baking sheet. Use a fork to press a crisscross pattern into the top of each cookie. Bake at 325 degrees for 10 minutes or until golden. Let cool before removing from sheet.

Gooseberry Patch Keepsake Cookbook

Ratings & Reviews

melissac's Review

April 12, 2014
They came out nothing like a cookie. I would highly recommend a recipe that uses flour.

FoxyRockie's Review

November 26, 2013

LPaladino's Review

November 12, 2012
I made these cookies based on the good reviews but was very disappointed in the results. Without the flour, etc of most traditional recipes this is just a ball of sugary peanut butter. It doesn't have the consistency or flavor of a cookie. If you're looking for a traditional cookie I would try another recipe.

IoneTaylor's Review

April 25, 2012
Easy and good. I liked that they used so few ingredients.

NatalieDK's Review

February 29, 2012
If you are looking for the easiest and tastiest peanut butter cookie recipe, THIS IS IT! My family loves them -- crunchy or smooth!

jessienagy's Review

October 24, 2011
Omg. My bf loves pb cookies and these hit the spot!

mamahewitt's Review

July 10, 2011
These were the easiest cookies ever to make...and super yummy. My husband and kids inhaled them. I used only half a cup of sugar because we don't like things too sweet, and they were still delicious. They don't hold up well for transport, however...I put some in a baggie and they turned into crumbles quickly. Tasty crumbles, at least!

Sporty's Review

June 13, 2011

KatrinaH's Review

February 06, 2011
I was prepared for disaster on making these cookies... how can a recipe so simple and easy, with so few ingredients, turn out great??!! Well, these cookies are TOO DIE FOR GOOD! They're soft, decadent, and delicious. They were gone the first night--my family all loved them. These are the best peanut butter cookies we've ever had!!