Very good, relatively easy, light, refreshing, and a nice mix of flavors. I used less fish sauce but I would use closer to the recipe next time. I used large scallops broken in half (I like the flavor better than bay scallops). I also mixed fennel with the endive and liked that very much with the oranges and the avacado. Works for a very light meal. I'm not sure what I would add to fill out the meal. Would actually rate as 3.5.