Photo: Johnny Miller; Styling: Sarah Smart
Hands-on Time
8 Mins
Total Time
8 Mins
Serves 6 (serving size: about 1/2 cup)

A few easy additions to store-bought ice cream create a custom flavor that simply tastes like Thanksgiving.

How to Make It

Break animal crackers into pieces. Place crackers and next 4 ingredients (through ginger) in a large bowl; gently mash with a potato masher until just combined. Spoon 1/2 cup ice cream mixture into each of 6 glasses or dessert bowls; top each serving with 1 tablespoon whipped topping.

Ratings & Reviews

danpdx's Review

December 01, 2013
This is an extremely simple recipe and delicious. I doubled this recipe, and used a carton of vanilla frozen yogurt (1 3/4 quarts total (about 7 cups.) I topped with a dollop of whipping cream and freshly grated nutmeg and served this in lieu of pumpkin pie this year. It was fabulous and everyone raved about it! It was comparable to a Dairy Queen Pumpkin Pie Blizzard. I used the masher to mix in the ingredients, leaving some small chunks of vanilla ice cream. I also froze the mixture over night knowing that mashing frozen yogurt would leave me with DQ blizzard like consistency. I would agree with the previous reviewer that the instructions could be clearer.

elinor3's Review

November 03, 2013
These instructions don't make sense. After mashing the crackers with the spices, it should say to blend the ice cream with the mixture before putting it into cups. Better yet, I'd refreeze the ice cream till firmer before serving.