Oxmoor House
Hands-on Time
12 Mins
Total Time
1 Hour 12 Mins
4 servings (serving size: 1 sandwich)

This classic New England sandwich comes together in a snap if you purchase lobster tails and have them steamed at the fish counter.

How to Make It

Combine first 11 ingredients in a large bowl, stirring well; cover and chill at least 1 hour. Divide lobster mixture evenly among buns.

Ratings & Reviews

Laurie18's Review

November 13, 2011
I'm a New Englander and we don't need anything but a toasted bun and lobster but this recipe was wonderful and I would make it again.

Jtsam220's Review

August 18, 2011

Jajooo's Review

August 08, 2011
Made these last night for the first time, and made exactly as written except that I omitted the tarragon and couldn't find New England style hot dog rolls so used brioche rolls instead. This was awesome - at first the dressing seemed liquid-y but then when I combined it with the lobster it was perfect, not too overpowering but very flavorful. This is expensive but a really nice treat! Does anyone know how to elegantly remove the steamed lobster meat from the tail?

KathrynNC's Review

July 25, 2011
I decided to try this recipe because lobster tails were on great sale at the grocery store this week. We thought this recipe was wonderful! I always finely dice celery in these kind of recipes - it just ruins the texture if you bite into a big chunk of celery. I spread just a little bit of butter (light butter with canola oil) on the inside of each bun and toasted them in the oven until lightly brown. Next time I may see if it's possible to purchase lobster meat already steamed and removed from the shell. One 4 oz lobster tail only yielded about 2.5 oz of meat. I served it with a side of oven waffle fries. I imagine it would also work well with corn on the cob or a green salad.

fairydragonstar's Review

July 03, 2011
this was excellent and easy to put together. I followed the recipe exactly and used some small lobster tails I had in the freezer that I boiled with a little kosher salt...the flavor was fresh and light