Annabelle Breakey
Prep and Cook Time
2 Hours
Chill Time
1 Hour 30 Mins
Yield
Makes about 70 cookies

These funky, old-fashioned treats make excellent food gifts. Because the cookies freeze well, bake an extra batch to enjoy in the New Year!

How to Make It

Step 1

In the bowl of a standing mixer fitted with a paddle attachment, beat butter and sugar until pale and fluffy, about 4 minutes. Meanwhile, sift flour, baking powder, and salt into a separate bowl.

Step 2

With mixer running, add egg and yolks one at a time, beating well after each addition. Add vanilla. Slowly add flour mixture and beat on low just until combined.

Step 3

Divide dough into thirds. Shape one third into a disk; set aside. Return another third to mixer, raise speed to medium-low, and add 1/4 tsp. peppermint extract and red food coloring; shape into a disk and set aside. Clean mixing bowl and paddle attachment. Put last third of dough in mixing bowl and beat in remaining 1/4 tsp. peppermint extract and green food coloring; shape into a disk and set aside.

Step 4

Draw a 6- by 8-in. rectangle on a sheet of waxed paper. Turn sheet over and lightly flour it. Working with one disk at a time, put dough in center of rectangle. Using a lightly floured rolling pin, your fingers, and a pastry scraper or a ruler, roll and shape each disk to fit rectangle. Layer each dough rectangle between sheets of waxed paper and chill at least 30 minutes and up to overnight. Let sit at room temperature for 5 minutes before continuing.

Step 5

Peel waxed paper from rectangles and put one sheet on counter; discard the rest. Set green dough on waxed paper. Top with red dough, lining them up as evenly as possible, and gently press down. Top red dough with plain dough. Gently roll dough stack with a rolling pin to seal layers, then trim uneven edges with a very sharp knife.

Step 6

Note: Store cookies, peppermint ends up, in an airtight container at cool room temperature or in refrigerator for up to 1 week. Freeze cookies for up to 2 months.

Step 7

Cut dough stack lengthwise into three 2-in.-wide columns. Cut each column crosswise into 1/3-in.-thick pieces. Lay pieces 2 in. apart on 3 parchment-lined baking sheets. Freeze 30 to 45 minutes. Meanwhile, preheat oven to 350°.

Step 8

Bake cookies 7 minutes, then switch positions of baking sheets and bake until bottoms are light golden brown, 7 minutes more. (You may need to bake in 2 batches if your oven won't hold 3 baking sheets; keep cookies in freezer until ready to bake.) Cool cookies on wire racks.

Step 9

Put chopped chocolate in a heatproof bowl that will fit over a pot with a few inches of water in it (bottom of bowl should not touch the water); set bowl aside. Bring water to a boil uncovered, turn off heat, and set bowl over water. Stir chocolate until melted and smooth. Dip each cookie about 1/2 in. into chocolate, then dip into or sprinkle with crushed candy. Set on waxed paper to harden (or chill in refrigerator 15 minutes).

Step 10

Note: Nutritional analysis is per cookie.

Ratings & Reviews

MarySue33's Review

MarySue33
November 20, 2012
N/A

lentzfive's Review

bakeloveit
December 13, 2010
These cookies looked great, very Christmasy and very professional...but did not taste like much. Too many wonderful tasting cookies out there to make these again.

karenfromboston's Review

ralphie
March 03, 2010
These are showstopper cookies. I adjusted the recipe ...ii added a quarter cup of cocoa to the white dough, and used dark chocolate and nuts for. The topping...beautiful and tasty addition to your cookie tins. Also, I sliced them and then froze them before baking, helped keep the cookies from splitting between the colors.

bakeloveit's Review

lentzfive
December 15, 2009
Haven't made these yet but make a cookie VERY close with a choc layer, cherry layer & almond layer. instead of using the rectangle directions. I line a loaf pan with plastic wrap & smash each layer in it on top of each other, then freeze (or put in fridge). Slice the loaf downthe middle & then slice each cookie off. VERY easy. I can't wait to try these.

ralphie's Review

AngelaB
December 08, 2009
These turned out very pretty and tasted good as well. That being said, I probably will not make these again due to the time they took to make. They were not difficult, but were VERY labor intensive! These took me 3 1/2 hours total to make. I wiped my knife with a damp paper towel after each cut of the dough. The wet knife made the cuts easier.

AngelaB's Review

Stanci
December 20, 2008
CUTE cookie for Christmas. They turned out like the picture. Not overly strong peppermint. If you like more peppermint to your cookie I would add more extract to the red dough. Worth the extra time measuring and slicing the cookie dough. I'll definitely add this recipe to my favorites :)

Stanci's Review

karenfromboston
December 16, 2008
I should start by listing the things I changed: I used almond extract instead of peppermint and did not do the dipping or sprinkles. This was because these cookies were for my daughter's school party and there were serious time constraints. But the recipe was wonderful! The cookies are so beautiful and they have that only-at-the-holidays taste. Would be YUMMY with coffee. Fairly labor intensive.