I agree with Jenni408, these look ridiculous. The better way to prepare these is to use a small cookie scoop and a mini muffin pan, then sink a mini PB cup down inside as soon as they come out of the oven. This way you get Reese's goodness in every bite (assuming you don't just pop the whole thing in your mouth!). Everyone I know loves them this way.
These were good, but they came out downright goofy looking. I bought the small peanut butter cups and the cookies expanded out so far on the plate and the peanut butter cups barely melted down (I squished em too) that they just looked silly. Tasted great, they were a hit at work. Maybe I would try the full size reeses next time