Sort by:
Newest
Newest
Oldest
01/23/2023
Adding to the chorus to say that this is a time consuming recipe. However, that's the only negative. The cookies are phenomenal tasting, my sister and I tag teamed this recipe last year and took the cookies to our jobs and we got tons of street (kitchen?) cred for them. My only regret making these is that they went way too fast, they were so good I wish I had more to enjoy.
I suppose if you want to save a little time, don't do the pumpkin faces, just do the rest. I am no professional decorator so doing the faces took me quite awhile, and after spending the time doing the rest of the cookies I was so stressed about messing up the faces and them not being presentable.
If you have the time, I highly recommend this recipe.
10/27/2009
Time consuming? Yes, but what took the time was piping on the faces on the pumpkins. Dropping the ingredients into the bowl wasn't the hard part. The cookies came out nice and soft with a perfect balance of spices. The marshmallow made for a nice surprise with that first bite and the cream cheese frosting gave it that little bit of extra sweet for a nice finish. I would definitely make these again, but not as an every-day cookie. Recipe was good as-it, wouldn't (and didn't!) change a thing!
10/19/2009
Far too many ingredients for a busy woman!! Much easier recipes out there!
Advertisement