This recipe was simple and good. I think it probably needs a minute more on each side; it was completely rare in the middle for us. Also, I do wish the potatoes were a little softer. I put them in the oven at 400 for a few minutes while I was preparing the roast, in addition to the time under the broiler, but they still could have used about 10 more minutes in the oven. The flavors of salt, pepper, and herbs were excellent and simple!
I put this in my crockpot, along with some new potato wedges (not frozen)and sliced carrots. I cooked it for 6 hrs on high. This has a lot of nice flavor to it and I will use this recipe again.
Both times I've made this dish I've had to put the beef in to cook longer even after letting it rest; somehow it's still raw. Otherwise, though, it's fantastic! I've been using dried herbs at appropriate dried/fresh ratios, but after the roasting it doesn't seem to matter. Perhaps it would be even better if I had fresh herbs to use, though. But this is perhaps the best beef and potatoes dish I've made. And the Brussels sprouts are great, too. My boyfriend prefers the sprouts with a little less lemon, but I like the amount in the recipe.
We chose this menu for a last-minute Birthday dinner because we had the main ingredients already on hand. Made the herb rub per recipe but used whole beef tenderloin. Had from-scratch Idaho wedges rather than prepared. The browned-butter Brussels sprouts were surprisingly excellent, we intentionally let the cut-sides color a bit in the pan. Very appealing on the plate, simple menu but very good.
Made as directed, including potatoes. Did not make brussel sprouts. VERY tasty, made the house smell great. This is worthy of company. Beef was tender and potatoes were perfectly crisp. Will def. make again.