Becky Luigart-Stayner
Yield: 6 servings (serving size: 1 sandwich)

Cola in the marinade tenderizes the meat. A simple homemade sandwich spread, made with mayonnaise and minced arugula, completes the sandwich. Serve with chips or fresh veggie slices.

How to Make It

Step 1

To prepare steak, combine first 7 ingredients in a large zip-top plastic bag. Add steak; seal and marinate in refrigerator for 2 hours, turning bag occasionally. Remove steak from bag, reserving marinade. Pour marinade into a microwave-safe bowl; microwave at high 2 minutes or until mixture comes to a boil. Set aside.

Step 2

Prepare grill.

Step 3

To prepare dressing, combine arugula and mayonnaise; set aside.

Step 4

Place steak on a grill rack coated with cooking spray; grill 8 minutes on each side or until steak is medium-rare or desired degree of doneness. Remove steak from grill; cover and let stand 5 minutes. Place onion slices on grill rack; grill 4 minutes on each side, basting occasionally with reserved marinade. Place rolls on grill rack, cut sides down; grill 2 minutes or until lightly browned.

Step 5

Cut steak diagonally across grain into thin slices. Spread 2 tablespoons dressing on bottom half of each roll. Divide steak, tomato, and onion evenly among bottom halves of rolls. Top with top halves of rolls.

Step 6

Wine note: A great steak sandwich like this one deserves a rich, fleshy red wine--one that will stand up to the savoriness of the grilled onions and the sweet meatiness of the steak. Since this is a sandwich, the wine shouldn't break the bank. My top choice: a California merlot. The Chateau Souverain Merlot 2001 (Alexander Valley, California, $18) is smooth, with hints of blackberries, plum, sage, and mushrooms. -Karen MacNeil

Ratings & Reviews

KarenWard's Review

January 14, 2013
Delicious sandwich, love the flavors of the arugula/mayo sauce and the sweet onions. Used a NY strip cuz they were on sale and it was perfect!

mikoprice's Review

July 07, 2012

Zesty1's Review

August 28, 2011
ABSOLUTELY LUV this steak sandwich recipe. When I cook it (and I cook it often) I am always amazed at how darn good this sandwich is. As indicated by the five stars given, this sandwich is truly outstanding! No need to alter any of the ingredients, perfect recipe just as posted!

kellywillhoite4's Review

June 20, 2009
This is one of our favorite recipes. We use filet instead of flank steak and the sandwiches are to die for. I am making tomorrow for my husband on Father's Day. It is one of his all time favorites!