Photo: Brian Woodcock; Styling: Claire Spollen 
Hands-on Time
24 Mins
Total Time
44 Mins
Serves 4 (serving size: 1 sandwich)

We love the combo of grilled cheese sandwiches and roasted tomato soup--so why not combine the two in each ooey-gooey bite?

How to Make It

Step 1

Preheat oven to 400°.

Step 2

Combine 1 teaspoon oil, tomatoes, and garlic on a baking sheet. Bake at 400° for 20 minutes. Remove skins from tomatoes; discard skins. Squeeze garlic to extract pulp; discard garlic skins. Combine tomatoes, garlic pulp, basil, salt, and pepper in a mini food processor; pulse 10 times.

Step 3

Combine mayonnaise and cream cheese in a medium bowl. Add cheddar, stirring well to combine (mixture will be very thick). Spread one-fourth of cheese mixture (about 2 tablespoons) over each of 4 bread slices; top each with about 1 1/2 tablespoons tomato mixture and 1 bread slice. Lightly coat outsides of sandwiches with cooking spray.

Step 4

Heat a large skillet over medium heat. Add 1 teaspoon oil; swirl to coat. Place sandwiches in pan; cook 3 minutes or until lightly browned (do not flip). Remove sandwiches from pan. Add remaining 1 teaspoon oil; swirl to coat. Turn sandwiches over, and add to pan; cook 3 minutes or until lightly browned and cheese melts. Cut in half; serve immediately.

Chef's Notes

MyRecipes is working with Let's Move!, the Partnership for a Healthier America, and USDA's MyPlate to give anyone looking for healthier options access to a trove of recipes that will help them create healthy, tasty plates. For more information about creating a healthy plate, visit

You May Like

Ratings & Reviews

KathrynNC's Review

March 06, 2015

Suze02's Review

November 23, 2014
I thought this was pretty good--served with tomato soup. Good on a cold day!

sukeedog's Review

November 08, 2014
Lovely flavor, though I think next time I'd combine the tomato mixture with regular shredded cheese and not bother with the mayo/cream cheese mixture. It made the sandwich more tangy, less cheesy, and I want my grilled cheese CHEESY. CL used this method (shredded cheese + mayo + cream cheese) in another recent grilled cheese recipe, and it's just not for me. But love the roasted tomatoes!

JeffAxelrod's Review

October 02, 2014
These are really delicious and definitely achieve the claim of getting grilled cheese and tomato soup flavor in one sandwich. I used Trader Joe's sourdough whole wheat boule and it was perfect for this. I'm not sure what lrose17 is thinking here--I thought this was a perfect and easy recipe; perhaps she's comparing it to making plain grilled cheese? Hands-on time was maybe 15 minutes. You can roast the tomatoes the night before to save time.

lrose17's Review

September 16, 2014
These were really good, but a lot of work. They're definitely not something you whip up on short notice. I can't claim that I measured every ingredient very carefully, but this only made three sandwiches for us.