Photo: Rick Lew; Styling: Sara Foster
Prep Time
10 Mins
Cook Time
20 Mins
Chill Time
8 Hours
Stand Time
30 Mins
Freeze Time
2 Hours
Makes about 1 quart

We flipped for this Fresh Peach Ice Cream in our Test Kitchen--the recipe got our highest rating--because it captures the taste of summer.

How to Make It

Step 1

Combine 3/4 cup sugar, egg yolks, and whole egg in a medium bowl. Scrape seeds from vanilla bean, and add seeds, pod, and half-and-half to saucepan. Warm over medium-high heat 8 minutes or until mixture begins to steam. Do not boil. Slowly whisk into egg mixture. Return to saucepan, and cook over medium heat, stirring constantly, 10 minutes or until mixture coats back of a spoon. Whisk in butter and cream. Let cool, and chill 8 hours.

Step 2

Toss peaches with remaining 1/2 cup sugar and salt; let stand at least 30 minutes in a glass or stainless bowl.

Step 3

Puree peaches and peach preserves in a blender until well combined but not completely smooth. Combine peach and custard mixtures, and freeze in an ice-cream maker according to manufacturer's instructions.

Seasoned in the South: Recipes from Crook's Corner and from Home; Crook's Corner, Chapel Hill, North Carolina

Ratings & Reviews

gotbidnezz's Review

August 19, 2012
I cut the sugar by about half and still found this recipe a bit sweet. I also didn't understand the butter, but the end result was good. Instead of the vanilla bean, I used two teaspoons plus a dash of vanilla extract. I would add another half teaspoon to teaspoon if I make it again.

jenmax's Review

June 30, 2012

angagc's Review

July 11, 2011
This ice cream recipe is amazingly rich. I used good vanilla extract instead of vanilla bean. I'll make it again with the usual - fresh Edgefield county peaches. I'll drive a hundred miles out of my way to get them from that area and it makes all the difference.

airforcemommy's Review

June 21, 2009
This ice cream was outstanding. We had it with peach pie for a special ending to Father's Day Sunday Lunch. I would make this again. The butter was an interesting addition to the recipe that I have never heard of before but the ice cream was all that it should be!