Chewy Red, White, and Blue Cookies
You can find red, white, and blue candies at supermarkets and discount stores before the Fourth of July.
Recipe by Southern Living July 2003
Sort by:
Newest
Newest
Oldest
04/09/2022
My family loves these! I've been making them exactly as written for years. Delicious cookie!
09/16/2016
If this recipe called for 1/2 cup of candy-coated chocolate pieces, I would have given it a 5. There was too much of the candy. Other than that, this was a very tasty cookie and I will try it again using less chocolate pieces.
07/03/2013
These were a bit sweet for me. I thought it odd that there was no salt in the recipe, so I added a generous 1/4 tsp, and it could have used more. I subbed agave for the corn syrup, but don't think that should make much difference. I did use unsalted butter. Hopefully they will travel well, as claimed!
08/05/2012
Didn't have 1 1/2 cups of peanut butter so just used a little less than a cup, but still came out great. i like my cookies a little crispy so left a couple batches in for a couple minutes longer - delish!
07/04/2010
These cookies really do stay chewy three days after cooking (and there weren't any left longer than that).
Advertisement