I don't see how any brownie recipe could be a bad one. These were AWESOME!!!
I didn't try these but they look delicious, and i plan to try them today.
We really liked these. How do you know you won't like something unless you really try it? I'm sure it depends on what you put on top. We did Hugs and Kisses, waffle pretzels, and M&M's. We're not crazy about nuts or peanuts, but would make them for friends who do. You just have to try it. You're right, don't rate it if you haven't made them. That's kind of rude in my opinion.
If you didn't make it, then don't rate it. That being said, I thought it was pretty tasty.
I did not make this because, I'm sorry it looks like trash.