I took this with me on vacation last summer and offered a slice to my mom, who can be a bit snarky. She immediately informed me, "I don't like carrot cake." Later that evening I caught her (out of the corner of my eye) taking a bite of the cake off someone's plate and I eventually saw her getting slices of the cake several times during our family vacation. I never said a word..... Seeing her going back for seconds, thirds, fourths, etc. was the greatest form of flattery, LOL!
I found my way here after seeing Chrissy Teigen post this recipe. I had high high expectations. It was good! But not sure it's the best I've ever had. It was still very moist, and good though. I think my palette prefers something a little less sweet. Because there's the buttermilk glaze underneath the cream cheese frosting, I think next time I would half the sugar in the cake recipe. I already made the cream cheese frosting with only 3/4 sugar.
I saw the layered version of this first, and was happy to see it also came as a sheet cake version. I found the glaze and frosting recipes to be too much for the sheet cake. Next time I will half the recipes for those. Other than that, it was absolutely delicious and will definitely be making this again!
This cake surpasses all carrot cake recipes. The glaze and buttermilk in the cake pushes it over the edge. Always rave reviews and usually it is the requested recipe for everyones birthday. I agree with previous review to refrigerate cake after adding the glaze and letting it cool and then frost the next day for perfect results!
I am a carrot cake fan...this is over the top incredible! I made it following the recipe, but made cupcakes. The glaze is delicious, the frosting is "fluffy"...but really it does not need the frosting, as the frosting overpowers the cake!
I've been making this carrot cake since the recipe first appeared. It's always a crowd pleaser and has become an Easter Tradition with my family. No other carrot cake can hold a candle to this!
I made this for my Mom's birthday and she said it was the best carrot cake she had ever tasted! It is a very moist, delicious cake...a little time intensive, but worth the effort. I made the cake and topped with the buttermilk glaze, but in fridge overnight and took out the next afternoon and added the cream cheese icing, let it come to room temperature before serving.
Anytime I make this cake I receive highest compliments! Definitely worth all the effort.
I made this for a neighborhood picnic, and though I thought it was good, it did not meet the high expectations I had for it, given the rave reviews. However, I got many requests for the recipe, and when I had a piece the next day, I thought it was FABULOUS -- it was much moister. The next time I make it, I will make the cake and put the glaze on the day before, and frost it on the day I serve it.
I know now that I will NEVER taste a carrot cake as great as this one! And what's so wonderful, I can make it MYSELF! I used to look forward to having carrot cake at one of my favorite restaurants, but not anymore. I can make the best carrot cake out there..THIS ONE! I prepare two of these every Easter. One for my coworkers, and one for my family.