Coconut Cream Pie will always remind me of my grandmother. I would ask her for the recipe, but it's one of those that isn't written down. She doesn't need a list of ingredients or directions, and she could probably make it with her eyes closed. She's had years of practice, and as much as I love baking, I'm not quite there yet. That's why I also love this Coconut Cream Pie recipe from Southern Living.
This pie has been dubbed "The Best" Coconut Cream Pie, and if you take a look at the ratings and reviews on the recipe, you'll see why. It has just the right amount of coconut flavor, and satisfies taste-testers of all kinds. This classic pie starts with a store-bought pie crust, but you could certainly make your own if you have a trusty homemade pie crust recipe. If not, take a look at our pie crust recipe collection!
The pie is filled with a custard that's made up of sugar, cornstarch, egg yolks, butter, and sweetened flaked coconut. The filling is then topped with homemade whipped cream and a sprinkling of toasted coconut. Perfection! Southern Living cherishes those old family recipes, which is why this one is a great option if you're looking for The Best Coconut Cream Pie.
Each day we’re featuring a how-to video so you can learn how to make your favorite recipes like a pro. Check back everyday for tips, tricks, advice, and recipe demos.