The answer may surprise you. 

By Corey Williams
June 23, 2020
Each product we feature has been independently selected and reviewed by our editorial team. If you make a purchase using the links included, we may earn commission.
Advertisement

Good news! Sometimes dessert may actually be the best medicine.* Here’s what you need to know about eating ice cream when you have a sore throat:

*Ice cream is not actually medicine. Contact your physician if your sore throat is severe or if it is accompanied by a fever. If you suspect your sore throat is caused by COVID-19, make sure to follow all CDC-recommend safety precautions and call your doctor ASAP. 

Dairy Is Bad For Colds: Fact or Fiction? 

Alexandra Grablewski/Getty Images

There’s a widely believed myth that dairy products, like ice cream and milk, make cold symptoms worse by increasing phlegm. 

While milk may make your mucus thicker (sorry for the imagery), it definitely won’t increase mucus production. 

If ice cream or a milkshake is what you need to make yourself feel better, then more power to you. 

Can Ice Cream Cure a Sore Throat?

Sadly, no, ice cream will probably not cure what ails you—especially if your sore throat is caused by a bacterial or viral illness. 

However, cold and creamy foods like ice cream can help ease your pain. If you’re struggling to eat other foods because of discomfort caused by swallowing, a few spoonfuls of a soothing frozen dessert provide much-needed relief (and calories). 

Avoid ice cream with rich, super-sweet sauces and additives, as they may irritate your already already-inflamed throat. 

Also, ice cream is obviously a bad idea if you are lactose intolerant or have a milk allergy. Try a dairy-free sorbet or popsicle instead. 

Are Hot Or Cold Foods Better For a Sore Throat? 

We Are/Getty Images

They both have benefits.

Cool foods and drinks lower the temperature of nerve endings in the throat, which reduces pain signals (via MedicalNewsToday). They can also provide a soothing effect. 

Warm drinks, meanwhile, are good because they promote salivation and help lubricate the throat. Ingredients, like honey and lemon, that are often added to warm teas and beverages provide other healing benefits. 

In fact, one of our favorite sore throat remedies just so happens to be Traditional Medicinals Organic Throat Coat Tea, which contains herbal ingredients like slippery elm bark and and licorice root to soothe your pain naturally (read all about this miracle elixir right here). 

Just make sure your drink isn’t too hot—the last thing you need right now is a throat burn.