40 Halloween Potluck Ideas

September 26, 2019
Photo: Jonny Valiant; Styling: Linda Hirst
Parties are way more fun if you don't have to do all the cooking, so host a Halloween Potluck and let your friends show off their favorite Halloween potluck ideas. The best potluck ideas are dishes that can be shared, but that doesn't mean you have to make it all main dish. Ask guests to sign up for courses so that you get a range of appetizers, desserts, mains, and sides, not fifteen plates of (adorable!) cupcakes. As host, you should provide the plates, utensils, and napkins, but you can also set up the bar if that makes party planning easier.
Start Slideshow

1 of 40

Halloween Ham and Cheese Hand Pies

Erin Kunkel
Halloween Ham and Cheese Hand Pies Recipe
This is an adaptable little recipe. We love the warm, spicy flavor of brown mustard, but feel free to use your family's favorite mustard. You can also customize the filling by using any kind of thinly sliced cheese and/or meat that you or your kids prefer.
Advertisement
Advertisement

2 of 40

Slow Cooker Chicken Chili

Photo: Brian Woodcock; Styling: Heather Chadduck Hillegas
Slow Cooker Chicken Chili Recipe
This slow-cooker chicken chili is a great addition to your cool weather weeknight meal rotation, especially when it comes to a Halloween potluck. Calling for a mixture of beans and hominy, this recipe boasts bold, rich flavor, something that can often be dulled in a slow cooker. Processing some of the beans in a food processor thickens the soup, lending a heartier flavor to the dish. We suggest serving the soup with green onions, cheese, cilantro, peppers, and plain yogurt, a great substitute for sour cream. Perfect for a potluck, ideal for cool weather, and guaranteed to make your home smell amazing while you're gone, this slow cooker chili is sure to make your "must make again" list.

3 of 40

Spinach Jack-O'-Lantern Hand Pies

Erin Kunkel
Spinach Jack-O'-Lantern Hand Pies Recipe
Turns out that spinach wrapped in pie dough passes the picky-eater test! For these Halloween riffs on the classic calzone, use 4- by 5-in. pumpkin-shaped cookie cutters (find at cooking or craft stores and online). Or cut out a pumpkin-shaped template from paper, set it on the dough, and cut around it with a thin, sharp knife.
Advertisement

4 of 40

Boneyard Chicken Pot Pie

Photo: Thomas J. Story
Boneyard Chicken Pot Pie Recipe

We made good old chicken pot pie Halloween party-worthy by loading up the filling with fresh vegetables and herbs, and decorating the top with bones and skulls cut from puff pastry. You'll need special cookie cutters; or you can create your own skull and bones from cardboard and cut around them on the pastry with a knife. For the best "puff," keep the pastry cold as you work.

5 of 40

Chicken Curry Moon Pies

Erin Kunkel
Chicken Curry Moon Pies Recipe
Toasting the cumin brings out its flavor, and a bit of Madras curry powder makes this a savory pie that's as appealing to grown-ups as it is to kids.

6 of 40

Devilish Chorizo Chili with Hominy

Greg DuPree
Devilish Chorizo Chili with Hominy Recipe

Not only is this chili easy to make ahead, it actually improves with time. If you like your chili very spicy, add an extra teaspoon of chipotle powder. Prep and Cook Time: 50 minutes. Notes: Prepare chili up to two days ahead. Cool, cover, and chill; reheat before serving. Buy the best-quality chorizo you can find, preferably from a butcher or Mexican market, and avoid the type of chorizo that is very soft and sold in plastic casings; it tends to break down too much in cooking. Substitute another spicy uncooked sausage if you can't find good chorizo.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

7 of 40

Boo-tiful Pumpkin Cake

Oxmoor House
Boo-tiful Pumpkin Cake Recipe

 

Make two recipes of this pumpkin cake and create your own tasty pumpkin!

8 of 40

Pumpkin-Chocolate Brownies

Photo: Greg Dupree; Styling: Heather Chadduck Hillegas
Pumpkin-Chocolate Brownies Recipe

TIP: Let fresh-baked brownies chill, uncovered, overnight. For a perfect slice, cut while they're cold. Serve at room temperature.

9 of 40

Spooky Sangria

Photo: Carol Shih; Styling: Margo True and Carol Shih
Spooky Sangria Recipe

What could be more fun than a cauldron full of seething, smoking sangria? It's delicious and wickedly strong (use more sparkling water if you want to dilute it a little). Although dry ice is not toxic, it's dangerous to swallow chips because of the extremely low temperature. Using a chunk of the ice, and wrapping it in cheesecloth, avoids that problem.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

10 of 40

Pumpkin-Shaped Crispy Grilled Cheese Sandwiches

Photo: Thomas J. Story
Pumpkin-Shaped Crispy Grilled Cheese Sandwiches Recipe
These chubby sandwiches have shredded cheese on the outside, which melts into a crunchy sheath as they cook. We used a Wilton 4 1/2-in. cutter for the large sandwiches and a 3 3/4-in. cutter for the smaller ones (find both as part of a nested set on amazon.com). Make these festive Halloween sandwiches alongside a pot of tomato soup for an easy dinner if you're having guests over to trick-or-treat.

11 of 40

Hallowed Eve Cheese Pumpkin

Oxmoor House
Hallowed Eve Cheese Pumpkin Recipe
Don't just settle for a typical appetizer. Mix things up this Halloween and serve this hauntingly-good cheese pumpkin masterpiece to your party guests.

12 of 40

Honey Chicken Wings

Honey Chicken Wings Recipe
You're sure to get a standing ovation when guests sample this sweet-hot salsa, honey, and ginger marinade. Bake the wings during the first quarter and serve at halftime with blue cheese or Ranch dressing.

 

 

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

13 of 40

Witch's Purse

Witch's Purse Recipe
Keep it simple by preparing just about everything ahead of time.

14 of 40

Ghostly Pizza

Photo: Antonis Achilleos; Styling: Lynn Miller
Ghostly Pizza Recipe
Frozen pizza dough is the secret to this easy pizza which is topped with slices of mozzarella cheese shaped like ghosts.

15 of 40

Mummified Cheese Log

Oxmoor House
Mummified Cheese Log Recipe
Shaping this log into a mummy is half the fun. Let the kids help decide how they want this cheesy mummy to look and then start sculpting!
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

16 of 40

Bucket o' Bones

Bucket o' Bones Recipe

17 of 40

Mummy Dogs

Photo: Jennifer Davick; Styling: Lisa Powell Bailey, Rose Nguyen
Mummy Dogs Recipe

These make-ahead hot dogs use refrigerated breadstick dough, perfect for goblins, pretty princesses, superheroes, and even their parents. Watch the how-to video at SouthernLiving.com.

18 of 40

Spiced Lamb Chops with Rosemary Crumbs

Photo: Thayer Allyson Gowdy; Styling: Miranda Jones
Spiced Lamb Chops with Rosemary Crumbs Recipe

These spiced lamb chops are great for cocktail parties, since you can eat them one-handed.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

19 of 40

Ghoul-Aid Punch

Ghoul-Aid Punch Recipe
Give your guests a scare by float a creepy ice face in your punch bowl. Fill a Halloween mask with water (seal the openings with sturdy tape), freeze overnight, then remove the ice from the mask and float face up.

20 of 40

Cauldron Full of Devilish Dip

Cauldron Full of Devilish Dip Recipe
Fill a bread bowl with a chunky Devilish Dip to create the look of a creepy bubbling cauldron.

21 of 40

Witch's Cauldron Chili

Photo: Becky Luigart-Stayner
Witch's Cauldron Chili Recipe
Prepare up to 2 days in advance and refrigerate. Reheat over low heat, stirring frequently. If it's too thick, stir in a little water.
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

22 of 40

Jack-o'-lantern Quesadillas

Jack-o'-lantern Quesadillas Recipe

23 of 40

Boil and Bubble Soup Cauldron

Richard Jung
Boil and Bubble Soup Cauldron Recipe

Notes: The hominy can pass for teeth and the green peas as beady little eyes. If making soup ahead, don't add peas; cover soup when cool and chill, then add peas when reheating. For a tureen, use a rustic pan, such as a cast-iron Dutch oven. Or you can use a pumpkin shell. You'll need a pumpkin at least 12 to 16 inches tall and wide. Cut off top and scoop out seeds. About 10 minutes before serving, fill shell with boiling water to warm. Drain and fill with hot soup. Use top as lid for the pumpkin tureen.

24 of 40

Jack-o'-lantern Cookies

Jack-o'-lantern Cookies Recipe
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

25 of 40

Halloween Spider Cookies

Sara Tane
Halloween Spider Cookies Recipe

Landing somewhere between adorable and slightly spooky, these Halloween spider cookies are sure to fulfill all your creepy-crawly sweet needs for your upcoming Halloween festivities. Using a classic cut-out butter cookie dough keeps the edges of your spider cookies shape neat and clean—no worries about the cookies expanding when they bake. Decorate these Halloween cut-out cookies with black gel icing, royal icing, candy eyes, orangle and black sprinkles, or whatever fun decorations you have on hand. These cookies make for a playful, spooky food craft that grown-ups and kids alike can enjoy.

26 of 40

Cheddar Witch's Fingers

Leigh Beisch
Cheddar Witch's Fingers Recipe
These ghastly little nibbles are rich with cheesy flavor, and a real snap to make. Prep and Cook Time: 55 minutes. Notes: Keep the dough cool as you work with it to prevent stickiness.

27 of 40

Pumpkin Butter

Photo: Antonis Achilles, Food Styling: Mary Claire Britton and Sarah Epperson; Prop Styling: Prissy Le
Pumpkin Butter Recipe

The maple syrup in this pumpkin butter recipe really darkens up the spread and adds some good depth of flavor. This easy recipe makes a lot, but you can easily cut the recipe in half for a small yield.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

28 of 40

Sausage Head Charcuterie Board

Time Inc. Video Studio 
Sausage Head Charcuterie Board Recipe

Sculpting a terrifying head using the components of a classic charcuterie board may be a labor of love, but for anyone who takes their Halloween entertaining seriously…  trust us, it’s so worth it. 

29 of 40

Frankenstein Cookies 

Photo: Darcy Lenz
Frankenstein Cookies  Recipe

Starting with refrigerated, store-bought cookie dough, these cooky Frankenstein cookies are an easy Halloween baking project to whip up this year. That said, packaged cookie dough is made to spread, so if you’d rather your Frankenstein cookies have rectangular or otherwise shaped faces (as opposed to these round-faced cuties), you can use a classic cut-out cookie dough that will better hold its shape.

30 of 40

Stuffed Pepper Mummies

E. Spencer Toy
Stuffed Pepper Mummies Recipe

 

An adorable take on jalapeño poppers, these sweet pepper "mummies" are stuffed with a gently spicy mix of Mexican chorizo, cream cheese, sharp cheddar, and cilantro.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

31 of 40

Graveyard Cake

Photo: Mark Thomas
Graveyard Cake Recipe

Halloween desserts definitely call for having a little extra fun in the kitchen. This kinda-cute, kinda-creepy Graveyard Cake is easy to make, fun to decorate (so recruit the kids’ help), and is sure to be a perfectly spooky centerpiece for any Halloween dessert table.

32 of 40

Frankenstein Cookie Bars

Thomas J. Story
Frankenstein Cookie Bars Recipe

These bars make a fun Halloween treat, and they're very flavorful: the green tea frosting cloaks a chewy-soft coconut-lime cookie. They're easy enough that the kids can help you make them.

33 of 40

Halloween Hummus

Photo: Caitlin Bensel, Styling: Mindi Shapiro
Halloween Hummus Recipe

For a truly spooky treat, this hummus is a great way to create a fun and festive Halloween effect. Simply fill a carved skull prop with this ghoulishly delicious hummus for a great appetizer to serve to guests. This hummus is red pepper based and features cayenne pepper, cumin, and plenty of garlic cloves for some great flavor. This dip is great to serve with crackers, chips, or veggie sticks. Dig right in, if you dare! 

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

34 of 40

Drogon’s Breath Cocktail

Time Inc. Food Studios
Drogon’s Breath Cocktail Recipe

In Game of Thrones lore, the dragon has three heads. And each would love to sate their thirst on this libation. A hint of bright citrus perfectly balances the rich earthy element the wine in this cocktail delivers. Refreshing, delicately sweet, and tangy, this drink if fit for a queen. Serves 1 Khaleesi

35 of 40

Black Sesame Cupcakes

Photo: Caitlin Bensel
Black Sesame Cupcakes Recipe

There's nothing artificial about these dramatically hued treats. Supermoist (and whole-grain) chocolate cupcakes get their blackout color from black sesame seeds and antioxidant-rich dark cocoa powder. These desserts are delicious and better for you, with every bit of fun, festive flair you crave.

36 of 40