My husband and I love this dish. I make it with 2 cups of leftover turkey and 2 small or 1 medium onion. It's quick, delicious and filling.
-
berquist9 Posted: 01/18/10
-
HBryant Posted: 09/14/10
I really enjoyed this. I used chicken instead of turkey. Also, when I put the mushrooms in the pan I also added carmelized onions and red wine vinegar b/c I didn't have sherry. It made for a very good taste. Wonderful! Will make again.
-
nycook7 Posted: 03/26/11
SO good!!!! Probably the best casserole I make regularly. Added about 2 TB of slivered almonds for crunch. Whole family, including 2 picky kids, loves it!
-
MaeJoyce Posted: 05/31/09
It was a great recipe, although a little bland, so I added garlic, a red bell pepper, onion, twice as many peas, twice as much cheese, crushed red pepper, and a can of mushroom soup along with everything else the recipe called for. I would definitely make it again. It's easy to make and will be great leftover.
-
smellgar Posted: 09/07/09
This is one of my "freezer favorites". I make a triple recipe and freeze two of the pans. I use chicken or turkey, whichever is cheaper the day I'm buying. I've also omitted the Sherry if I don't have any on hand with no problems. I don't know if I'd classify this as a dish for company, but it's a great hearty meal in the winter or fall and relatively cheap to make.
-
Belladonna714 Posted: 01/30/10
I thought was good, although a little bland in my opinion. Made the following changes: substituted a bone in honey brined turkey breast, (which I baked) for the turkey cutlets, used angel haor pasta instead of vermicelli, and greek yogurt in place of souir cream. Also used whole wheat panko breadcrumbs. I would make this again but will need to figure a little something extra to add to bring the flavors together.
-
dawnmarie41 Posted: 02/22/10
i have my own recipe for turkey tetrazzini, this one is ok but i use celery instead of peas. also i do not use onion powder. lots of black pepper
-
jsherry47 Posted: 02/22/10
I used to have the Woman's Day Encyclopedia of Cookery until I moved and couldn't take it with me. Space issues. This was one of my favorite recipes and I have been looking for a similar one ever since. This is very close if not right on. Thanks so much!
-
Tiffsta6715 Posted: 01/11/11
This recipe was fast and OK, not great. I definetly wouldnt use turkey cutlets again. Id bake chicken or turkey breast in the oven real fast or use already cooked meat. The sauce was way too thick I used 1 Cup 1% milk and it was still too thick after baking in the oven, or maybe it was just too much sauce...I added more peas (1Cup) and less mushrooms (1-1/2 packages). There was still a ton of mushrooms! I cant imagen using 2 whole pacakages. Id say one package is plenty. I also omitted the sherry because I didnt have any. After reheating, the sour cream broke a bit but not too much...
-
Kristilyn1 Posted: 03/01/10
I guess I probably should give it 4 stars, because for what it is...I think it's an excellent recipe. But I don't think I'd be serving this for a special occasion. This is a good, solid casserole that is family friendly. I didn't realize I was out of mushrooms until I had already started, but my fussy kids would prefer it that way anyway. My kids are not big casserole eaters, so the fact that they were interested in me making this again---says it all. It also does not taste light even if made exactly as written.
-
erinsv Posted: 02/23/10
This one is a favorite in my house. I make ahead when the baby is napping and leave it in the fridge until I'm ready to throw it in the oven. Though I don't make it for guests, I do serve it to the in-laws. We look forward to using turkey leftovers to make this dish
-
amandanorell Posted: 05/02/11
This is just a good recipe. It is not great nor is it bad. The flavor and texture is reminiscent of everything you love about casseroles. The one thing that makes this a good but not a great recipe is the turkey and it's preparation. The cutlets, were too thin, dry and lacking in flavor. In the future I would maybe prepare the cutlets differently or even consider using a different meat.
-
steponme Posted: 04/06/11
Thought this was a tasty weeknight meal. I served with blanched/sauteed green beans and garlic bread. This will go into may meal rotation.
-
swmillen Posted: 11/02/11
I added tyme, sub'd the turkey with chicken breasts, and broke the pasta in half before adding it to the water - I think this really helped for serving and eating.Since I don't care for mushrooms, I used more peas and added celery. Will make again.
-
BioSuze Posted: 12/30/11
Definitely a little bland. I added extra onion powder, lots of sherry, and extra cheese. Much better with these additions.






Beef and Sugar Snap Stir-Fry