I thought this was awful. I looked the recipe over and over thinking I had made a mistake. It's a lot of work and the sauce is basically tomatoes with no taste and it's so runny. I did not even like the meatballs. I was very disappointed and I followed the recipe exactly. I would rather a thicker, more rich sauce but I thought I would try something different - now I'm left with tons of leftovers and no one to eat them after a lot of work.
Spaghetti and Meatballs
bethany Posted: 11/11/08
JanetMcD Posted: 07/03/09
My kids really liked it. I thought the meatballs could stand a little more flavor. I had to substitute the turkey sausage for pork sausage. I will make it again, but I think I will add parmesan.
griebus Posted: 01/07/10
Great dish, especially the sauce. The meat balanced nicely with it. It's a thin sauce, so if you want it thick like store-bought marinara, cook it longer, but we loved it as written. Only change was to add a bit of cayenne.
MMowry Posted: 08/08/09
This has been my family's go-to meatball recipe since I clipped it several years ago. I 've made it for many dinners and special occasions to rave reviews. I always use hot italian turkey sausage and usually double the recipe and freeze some for crazy weeknights.
CESquires Posted: 08/14/09
This sauce is my favorite. It is delightful. All you taste is tomatoes, and that's exactly what spaghetti sauce should taste like! I usually use a bit more tomato paste to make the sauce a little thicker. I use this sauce on a regular basis for spahgetti, eggplant parm, and other recipes. Everyone should try this sauce at least once!
JIMMIC Posted: 04/27/10
As an âeditorâs pickâ I had expectations that this would be good, or great. The sauce was bland and watery. Egg substitute and an egg? This does not make a lot of sense. The instructions say to make 32 meatballs; a size indication would have been nice, instead of making the reader guess. The amount of time versus the resulting taste was not worth the effort. This was a major disappointment.
doherty Posted: 06/05/10
I used panko breadcrumbs and left out the sausage for the meatballs and they came out great. I used store bought sauce
Daisie Posted: 08/02/11
Just blah. Even with extra simmering time the flavors in the sauce didn't meld and the meatballs were no better than frozen meatballs from the grocery store. We were disappointed.
smancusi Posted: 01/27/12
Don't use the spaghetti sauce part of the recipe, but this is my weekly meatball recipe and my Italian husband says they are awesome!
CheleDot Posted: 04/27/13
We love making this recipe, but we buy the sauce instead of making it. Tastes great and is a good comfort meal.
Saraliza Posted: 04/19/13
The meatballs were very tasty; the sauce was rather bland. We baked the meatballs and didn't put them in the sauce, and that probably would have made a difference in the flavor of the sauce. Will probably do it again with a different sauce.
stellacorona Posted: 12/03/13
great meatball recipe. i use the marinara recipe from CL oct 2001. only marinara i make. everyone loves that one.
RLoushin Posted: 09/23/13
Prepared as written except I didn't have egg substitute so used an extra egg. Meatballs have great flavor. Use a scan 1.5" scoop to get 30-32 meatballs. I thought the sauce was plain, but my husband insisted it was better - not acidic, just pure tomato taste. Too watery for my taste. I would like to try crushed tomatoes perhaps. Much fresher than bottled sauce.