Great cookie! I made them large using a cookie scoop then rolled in sugar and baked for 13 minutes. This yielded 32 tender, slightly crisp delicious cookies. Due to time constraints I softened my butter in the microwave and mixed the batter by hand doing a thourough creaming of butter/shortening and non dry ingredients. I share this because slight variations in technique make a big difference. These really were good cookies!
jellybean65 Posted: 12/11/08
Genkimari Posted: 01/14/10
Snickerdoodles are my hubby's favorite cookies and he loves these! I would definitely make them again and a friend actually just asked me for the recipe. They also keep for a very well. :)
AugustFR Posted: 09/01/11
The Best snicker-doodles I have ever had, but beware how many cookies it makes!!! :)
JulioJ Posted: 12/21/13
Whew, I almost rated the wrong recipe. This is the recipe you should be looking for. Darn near impossible to mess this one up. Whenever I try to make something new and fail, I come back to this. They are also my personal favorite, and it yields enough cookies to share with friends. They are so good they gave me a bit of a reputation as a baker :)