Surprisingly great. Made to recipe with two big exceptions -- we had about a cup of leftover apple cider, so used that in the measure of 3c water & didn't strain the soup. Dripped half-and-half on the individual servings and lightly sprinkled with cayenne. Gorgeous.
Roast Butternut Squash Soup with Apples and Garam Masala
Comments and Reviews 1-8 of 8
carolfitz Posted: 02/21/11
Debsuny3 Posted: 11/11/08
Very tasty! I will make this again. I used the store bought Garam Masala.
RedSharpie Posted: 11/27/08
Absolutely delicious, and I'm usually not a big soup fan! I cut the recipe in half, used homemade chicken stock instead of canned, butter in place of oil, fuji apples instead of braeburn, and cream instead of the half-and-half. I also did not strain the soup because I liked the thickness. Will definitely be making this again with the full recipe for maximum leftovers!
ViennaVAfoodie Posted: 09/29/09
I will say that this does taste better than any butternut squash soup i've had. However, I didn't get the complexity of the flavors like I was hoping. I didn't taste the shallots, apples or maple syrup. It was a disappointment. Plus, I cut up like the whole squash and it too a very long time. For all the time and effort to get this result, I will not make it again.
docmom2 Posted: 01/26/09
Excellent. I lost the cooking light magazine it came in and needed to find the recipe online. Very thick and creamy, great for a cold winter night. Can't wait to make it again.
RenoTX Posted: 02/12/10
This soup is excellent. I had a made a different, much more bland CL recipe for squash soup a few months ago, and this one is much better. I halved the recipe and used red wine b/c that is what I had on hand. I used organic curry powder instead of garam masala. Couldn't really taste the apples, but the overall flavor was complex and really fresh. Will definitely make this again. My husband raved.
cusefoodie Posted: 09/19/10
Amazing! So delicate and flavorful. I used one small butternut and one small acorn squash. I also followed the advice to make my own garam masala - roasting the spices whole before grinding. I used a Cortland apple. I blended everything with an immersion blender and didn't sieve it. I let it sit and cool slightly before serving. The flavors are too delicate for a hot soup. I added the 1/2 & 1/2 to the bowls individually. This is definitely entertaining worthy - but simple enough for a Sunday dinner. Thanks for the great recipe!
MWhets Posted: 02/05/12
This was delicious! I made it exactly as recipe stated, and served it with a drizzle of cream and sprinkle of red pepper, based on another reviewers suggestion. I served this as first course with sourdough bread, and everyone loved it. Great recipe!