I have already made this cheesecake twice since the November Sunset came out. We used chocolate graham crackers instead of chocolate wafer cookies. You can definitely taste the orange if you use 2, but I really liked that! I didn't notice the maple syrup, but overall this was amazing! It was one of the most beautiful cheesecakes I've ever made. Yum!!
Pumpkin-Orange Cheesecake with Chocolate Crust and Salted Caramel
HaleyF Posted: 11/22/11
stacie296 Posted: 12/06/11
I am glad a previous low review was removed. I noticed that they rated this recipe low strictly on the basis of being unable to find the chocolate wafers to purchase. Totally unfair for what was an OUTSTANDING recipe. This got rave reviews from many at our Thanksgiving get-together. The only thing I would mention is that the orange zest is really strong and it overpowered the pumpkin a bit. But even so, who can complain about an orange and chocolate cheesecake?
cvanake Posted: 11/26/11
Delicious, and easy! This is the 2nd year we've had this for Thanksgiving dessert, and it's a keeper. Not a fussy cheesecake recipe - it cooks evenly and looks beautiful. I used the Nabisco chocolate cookie wafers as prescribed - they're generally available at Safeway or other major grocery chains but you may have to search to find them. My local Safeway keeps them in the ice cream aisle with the ice cream toppings!
amyinthelbc Posted: 11/16/11
This is really delicious, but extremely sweet. I tried this out pre-Thanksgiving and found a few things I would change. First of all, the chocolate cookies are nearly impossible to find. I had to use oreo cookie crusts as a substitute. I like the combination of pumpkin, chocolate, and caramel, but I found the orange zest and maple syrup a bit overpowering. Next time, I would use only 1 orange, omit the maple syrup, and add more pumpkin and pumpkin pie spice. It might be even better with a ginger snap crust.
Edandjake Posted: 12/28/11
I made this dessert for Thanksgiving also. It turned out great and the guests said it was good, but it was not as big a hit as the custard or pecan pies. This is a very "busy" cheesecake with a lot of competing flavors. The salt is a nice addition, but I agree with the comments about decreasing the amount of orange and the maple syrup does get lost. I used Trader Joe's "Chocolately Cats Cookies for People" for the crust - it worked really well. I probably will not make this one again.
rubymtngirl Posted: 02/04/12
This cheesecake was a hit!! I have Celiac and used a box of gluten free chocolate cookies that I found at Raleys for the crust. I would add more pumpkin spice and I didn't taste the maple syrup. The flavors were complex, which my family appreciates. This recipe has been added to our fall favorites!