I guess my opinion differs from the others...I thought this pie was good, not great. I had high expectations from the other reviews, but felt that this was one case where the picture looked better than the pie tasted. It's a fine pie, and certainly hasn't gone to waste, but I don't think I'll make it again. When I taste the graham cracker crust, I can't help wishing I was eating a key lime, lemon icebox, or even cheesecake. Good pie, just not great, in my opinion.
Peanut Butter-Banana Icebox Pie
Comments and Reviews 1-6 of 6
hokie98 Posted: 07/08/12
YankeeBelle1863 Posted: 06/30/12
Everyone who tried this raved and raved about it. They could not believe how good it was. Also received an immediate request to make it again SOON!
PaulaJager Posted: 07/05/12
PattiG61 Posted: 06/08/12
This pie turned out exactly like it looked in the picture! A huge hit with the men in my family. The chocolate layer and the honey roasted peanuts make this pie a sweet surprise! Absolutely delicious!
MontanaKydd Posted: 06/23/12
This pie is outrageous!!! I took it to work for an afternoon treat and had two marriage proposals! LOL I used bitter sweet dark chocolate and the men loved the combo of the peanut butter, banana, and chocolate. I have made this pie 3 times in 3 days.
ihbgal Posted: 06/16/12
All I can say is WOW ! What a sensational desert. Absolutely sure to be a hit with any crowd !