This was a disappointment. The chicken had a flour-y taste. Patches of flour were visible on several pieces even though I was careful to shake off the excess and sprayed each piece with PAM. The only change I made from the recipe was to use foil to cover the baking sheet instead of parchment. I doubt that made a big difference. I'd try it again except the dish is too time-consuming.
klem01 Posted: 03/01/09
apshine Posted: 11/15/09
This is a great substitute for fried chicken. The texture and flavor are so close, why go for all the fat of fried chicken?
nevacation Posted: 06/08/09
this was awesome! I have tried many oven fried chicken recipes and this is so good. the buttermilk definitely makes it. I didn't even marinate the whole hour and it was so juicy and moist. I did leave out the red pepper for the kids' sake, but very tasty. I also made it with the garlic fries and they were sinfully good.
SharonDeol Posted: 01/11/09
Made this for the first time - as an alternative to the January 2009 CL oven-fried chicken recipe. This recipe looked easier to do and the reviews were great so went for it. It was very easy to make and the results were great! My husband, a "foodie," who has longed for me to make fried chicken, was pleasantly surprised with how delicious the chicken was. And I was pleased to find a "fried" chicken recipe that was so low in saturated fat. Will definitely make this again and again. Served it with the Cole Slaw recipe from the January 2009 CL Mag, as well as a side of mashed potatoes. Almost like a KFC meal, only much tastier, healthier and cheaper having home-made!
NutsinNormal Posted: 10/07/09
What a surprise! If I hadn't read the ratings, I would never have tried this recipe. I'm just not a huge pepper fan and the ingredients didn't look too appealing. But everyone seemed to like it so well, I decided to go for it. My husband and I both loved this chicken ...it was peppery, but it worked. We fought over the last piece! I'll definitely make this one again.
LynnieM Posted: 01/14/09
I made this last night and it was delicious and very,very moist. A great way to do chicken without frying. Will definitely make again...the entire family loved it!!
dpkp03 Posted: 03/16/09
This is the best oven-fried chicken recipe from CL that I've tried. I gave it 5-stars but would not serve it for a special occassion or for company. I prepared the recipe as directed except as noted below. First, I used boneless thighs and adjusted cooking time accordingly. The spice/flour coating was just enough for 5 thighs. Secondly, I coated my baking sheet with aluminum foil sprayed with PAM. When turning the chicken and when removing it after it was baked, sections of crust stuck to the foil. Next time I will use parchment paper. I served the chicken with coleslaw and mashed potatoes.
krispy6372 Posted: 03/18/11
I'm sorry to disagree with the great reviews but this was a disappointment. I followed the recipe to a T, but I had problems getting large portions of the flour to cook off of my chicken. I ended up having to pan fry the chicken in the end too cook it off. The chicken was moist, but the coating was very bland. I wouldn't make this again.
tifferlopez Posted: 08/13/09
This recipe is quick, easy, and calls for ingredients we always have on hand. I've even made it with regular milk instead of buttermilk and it turned out great. We use whole wheat flour and my boyfriend usually thinks it makes things taste too "healthy", but it doesn't even cross his mind with this chicken. This one is definitely a keeper!
MichelleH29 Posted: 07/26/10
Ok, not worthy of a special occasion, but still quite yummy (4 stars). Made a batch and a half of this, pieces of chicken I used were rather large, so I baked them extra 10 minutes. Hubby loved it--I subbed McCormick Chicken Grill Sensations spice combo for the spices and enjoyed thoroughly. Will make again--and yes, very messy breading process, worth it :) Served with farm fresh corn-on-the-cob yum!
mommyedy Posted: 08/16/11
this recipe is a hit every time! the few changes I make are: skipped the buttermilk due to allergies, cut the cayenne in half for the kids and replaced half the flour with cornmeal for extra crunch.
Basset_Hound Posted: 12/28/11
This was delicious and easy. It reminded me of the fried chicken Mom used to make, without the mess or the guilt. The buttermilk marinade gave it an interesting "tang" and the cumin added flavor. I will definitely make it again.
smd1212 Posted: 02/19/14
I've been making this for years, it's a regular part of our kid-friendly (now voracious teen-friendly) rotation! I always triple the flour and spices accordingly or there wouldn't be enough coating (or flavor). I also use only boneless, skinless chicken thighs, with as much visible fat removed as possible, after trying other parts of chicken - the bone in is messy to eat and boneless breasts get too dry. With my oven on the convection bake setting at 450 degrees, boneless thighs are done after 25 minutes (I check with my instant read thermometer and it's always over 170 degrees internal temp). We like spicy, so along with tripling the recipe spices I use plenty of cracked black pepper instead of white, and add 1/4 tsp each of garlic powder, onion powder, and smoked paprika. Also, to get a nice crunch and not have patches of dry floury coating, you can't be shy with the cooking spray - I always spray both sides so there are no dry and floury bits and it fries up nicely in the oven.