I served these at a recent playgroup at my house, and everyone raved. I did make some healthy modifications, though: I eliminated the white sugar altogether, and subbed honey for the corn syrup. The raisins (which I kept at 1 cup) added plenty of sweetness to the cookie without all the extra sugar. Next time I'll try adding coconut or perhaps grated carrot for texture and fiber. I did not find the cookie to be too dry at all. Overall, an outstanding recipe!
Oatmeal Cookies with A-Peel
Comments and Reviews 1-6 of 6
Diplocook Posted: 01/28/09
karynk Posted: 12/22/08
I don't know what went wrong, but these were the most dry and tasteless oatmeal cookies ever. I don't know what all the other reviewers were doing that I didn't do.
swimnfred6 Posted: 02/22/10
Thanks for all the suggestions :) I modified the recipe as follows and it turned out DELICIOUS...I used raisins for baking, omitted white sugar, reduced flour to 1c. total (1/2c. all-purpose and 1/2c. whole wheat); substituted honey for corn syrup; added 1t. cinnamon and 2 heaping t. flax. Moist, flavorful cookie with lots of nutritional value. This ones a keeper!
PatSea Posted: 03/10/11
Great cookie, used ground pecans instead of walnuts. Not fond of corn syrup, will substitute with honey next time. I heated the cranberries with orange juice for one minute in the microwave. Very moist cookie!
garlockc Posted: 10/28/11
A very good, healthy cookie recipe. I also chose to emit the white sugar and instead of light corn syrup substituted 1T Agave Nectar. I also added about 2T of finely grated carrot and used wheat flour. The orange flavor really gives these cookies an extra punch and complements the dried cranberries very well. Try it!
ivannar89 Posted: 02/29/12
I loved these cookies. Did not use walnuts or orange peel. I followed some of the suggestions and also added ingredients from another oatmeal cookie recipe. I only used 1/3 cup of both sugars. Also reduced flour to 1c. Half of white, half of whole wheat. I microwaved the cranberries in the orange juice. Added 1t. cinnamon, 1 c. coconut flakes, and 1 tsp. vanilla. Came out delicious, moist, and chewy. Thanks everyone!