This cake comes out beautifully! The cake was very very moist. Next time i may add some maple syrup and/or bourbon to the frosting mixture to give it some added depth. I used more pecans than what were called for and sprinkled them on both layers, not just the top layer. This cake is sweet (but not overpoweringly so), so serve with ice cream.
Double-Caramel Turtle Cake
Comments and Reviews 1-10 of 13
aeroncaskb Posted: 09/13/09
CMLucas Posted: 01/25/11
This has to be the best cake I ever made - it was sooo good. I served it at a birthday party and got rave reviews. I used a boxed Devil's Food cake, I made a homemade caramel drizzle, I toasted the pecans in the same pan that I used to prepare the frosting which just put a very light candied coating on them and I added about 2 Tbs Bailey's Caramel Irish Cream to the frosting. That made the frosting smoother, less sweet and really amped up the flavor. I will make this again - no question.
Melioh Posted: 09/30/10
I must have tried five different ways to ruin this recipe and it still turned out delicious. I used light butter, I thought the extremely soupy batter would never turn into cake, I baked it in dark cake pans in my lop-sided oven at 325,and my caramel was a month and a half past its expiration date. And no, I don't have low expectations. It was very good.
saffrongoddess Posted: 09/05/09
Best chocolate cake base, ever. Cooking Light, please feature this cake in a stand-alone recipe. It is perfectly moist, rich, and delicious. I have layered it with almond paste, pistachio custard-buttercream, and ganache to make an 'Eclair Cake' that is out of this world. Technique is key with this recipe. I follow the recipe very carefully, and it's perfect every time!
CurlyQKate Posted: 07/09/10
Made this cake for my girlfriends last night. Everyone loved it! The flavors go very well together. I added mini chocolate chips between the two layers and also on top for some extra chocolate goodness. :o) Paired nicely with dessert wine too.
MeMyselfAndPie Posted: 04/24/10
I over-baked the cake, so it came out a little dry. Bummer. Other than that, it was delicious. My mom makes this recipe almost every week and loves it. I think I'll give it a second try and take it out much sooner. Step-by-step photos on my blog: http://me-myself-and-pie.blogspot.com/2010/03/double-caramel-turtle-cake.html
VaDragonlady Posted: 02/11/11
I have been making this cake since it first appeared in CL a few years ago and it is a favorite among family and friends. It is a standing order from my best friend's husband for his birthday every year!
lelkerton Posted: 08/02/10
I made this cake for a friend's birthday and we all loved it, especially my 5 year old daughter. I did add a little extra pecans on the top. This cake will definitely be a yearly tradition.
trish31 Posted: 08/19/10
If I make this in the morning to serve at night, should I refrigerate it?
DoctorT Posted: 12/27/11
Delicious. We had this for Christmas Day desert with some cream. However, delicious on its own or with ice cream as well. Be sure to add sufficient milk when beating the frosting. I didn't add enough and it started to set quite solid -very yummy regardless of my error! Reminds me of the pralines in New Orleans.
barbarafeltch08 Posted: 03/14/12
This recipe is terrific! Made it with my mom yesterday and it was perfect! It turned out what we expect. If you are looking for more tasty and delicious cake recipes -- Now is the right time to make one just watch the videos and follow list of cake recipes at www.everything-cake.com, www.gourmandia.com and www.gourmetrecipe.com for more exciting and delectable recipes. Have fun!!
MargaretPybas1 Posted: 09/13/12
I made the cake for coworkers birthday. It got rave reviews. I used dark chocolate cocoa. It was rich and moist.
sunshyne Posted: 02/08/13
This cake is very moist. I use dark chocolate cocoa and skip the frosting. Top with powdered sugar, whipped cream or chocolate sauce. Yummy!