Everyone asks for the recipe for this potato salad. It's just perfect!
Classic American Potato Salad
Lauren98 Posted: 01/07/09
DeeDoheny Posted: 07/04/12
Really enjoyed this recipe. My 18 year old son likes it a lot because it's not overly heavy on the mayo. Easy recipe for a good, basic potato salad.
sharonrc Posted: 05/24/12
This sounds like mine, only I use sweet pickles and mustard with the mayonaise. Plus I add a lot of onions.
nancur Posted: 07/03/12
Good basic recipe except DON'T use russett potatoes. Those are baking potatoes and do not yield the same consistency when cooked. I used red potatoes with far better results. Also cut the parsley in half so it would not be so overwhelming.
kafe31 Posted: 05/24/12
Have'nt tried it yet. Sounds great!! !!!
hannahsgirl Posted: 08/01/12
this is a good recipe but I use dill salad cubes instead of sweet/bread and butter, add diced Pimento and French's mustard for a down south tangy potato salad. And I also use Russet potatoes. Comes out GREAT every time.
SamCummiskey Posted: 05/25/14
Hands down best potato salad I have ever had. I did make some changes though-- used red potatoes instead of russets and I used half the mayo. It was just enough to hold it together and it got rave reviews from everyone.