Cheddar and Hot Mustard Sandwiches

Traditional English pub fare inspired the robust flavor of these simple sandwiches. Serve with ale or Merlot.

Yield: 4 dozen
Recipe from Oxmoor House

More From Oxmoor House


  • 3 cups (12 ounces) shredded sharp Cheddar cheese
  • 1 (4-ounce) jar hot mustard (we tested with Inglehoffer)
  • 1/2 cup minced onion
  • 1/4 cup mayonnaise
  • 12 slices pumpernickel bread, crusts removed (we tested with Pepperidge Farm)
  • 12 slices sourdough bread, crusts removed (we tested with Cobblestone Mill)


  1. Combine first 4 ingredients in a bowl; stir well. Spread about 3 tablespoons cheese mixture onto each pumpernickel bread slice. Top each with a sourdough bread slice. Cut each sandwich into four squares. Arrange sandwiches on a serving platter, some pumpernickel side up and some sourdough side up.
  2. Polka-Dot Sandwiches: To make sandwiches more artistic, cut 4 small circles from each pumpernickel slice and 4 small circles from each sourdough slice using a 3/4" to 1" biscuit cutter. Place the white sourdough circles in holes in pumpernickel. Place the brown pumpernickel circles in the holes n the sourdough slices. Assemble sandwiches as directed.
My Notes

Only you will be able to view, print, and edit this note.

Add Note

Cheddar and Hot Mustard Sandwiches Recipe at a Glance
  1. Enter at least one ingredient

Find out what we've got cooking...

Weekly Specials
Get our Free Weekly Specials Newsletter filled with our favorite recipes, seasonal menus, and special features.
We Respect Your Privacy. Privacy Policy