THIS WAS THE BEST CARROT CAKE I HAVE EVER HAD!!! I highly recommend this to everyone for any occasion. Be creative and put the frosting in a ziplock and use it to make designs on your cake (on top of the first layer of frosting). Enjoy the cake!
4evervicky Posted: 08/11/09
kschoeneck Posted: 12/21/09
This was my first attempt at carrot cake and everyone loved it!!!!!!
MeMyselfAndPie Posted: 02/19/10
Delicious. I made this for my dad's birthday and he LOVED it. (Carrot cake is his favorite.) The apple butter really adds something special. And the cream cheese frosting is so good. Much better then the kind you get at the store. Very rich and creamy. I sprinkled mine with chopped walnuts and it looked very pretty. Step by step photos on my blog: http://me-myself-and-pie.blogspot.com/2009/11/carrot-cake-w-cream-cheese-frosting.html
momto4girlz Posted: 12/30/11
Pretty pleased overall w/ how this recipe turned out. This rating/review is for the cake only-- I used my own cream cheese frosting recipe. I only had 9 inch cake pans, so I had to cut back on the cooking time--took about 27 minutes. The only problem I had (and it is a big problem) is that both layers stuck to the bottom of the pan--terribly. I thought I was going to have to toss the whole thing and start over, but I was able to salvage the stuck portions and piece each layer back together before it cooled. I thought it would fall apart when sliced, but it actually stayed together very well. I'm still not sure what caused it to stick so. I thought it was odd that the recipe said to grease the pans w/ cooking spray only, but I did it anyway. Next time I make this, I will grease w/ shortening AND flour the pan. Carrot cake is my daughter's favorite, and it's so nice to have a lighter version. We didn't miss the extra calories at all! .
Bunster Posted: 01/20/12
This is a very good recipe that I enjoy making, although I think that the baking time should be reduced by 3-5 min, I'd start checking the cakes at 30 min, it's really done on the edges at 35, but with frosting, the cake ends up ok. I add toasted coconut on the icing, and I recommend doing the frosting equal parts butter and cream cheese (enough frosting and it is creamy enough), I did 4 oz each.