Haha, we liked this. Boy am I glad I didn't read these harsh reviews. I will use less tomato next time.
Comments and Reviews 1-10 of 10
suebook Posted: 04/15/10
MelissaD67 Posted: 09/21/10
I just made this for my 9 year old twins and it was a hit! I don't understand why the reviews are so blah. I did use top round steak and tenderized it with the meat hammer...it was plenty tender. I also used a 2X concentrated tomato paste from a tube and used only 2 TBS. We will definitely make this again!
Tippyj Posted: 01/15/10
This was a yummy dish! I did add more worchestershire though. I guess this is something you either love or hate. My hubby and I both enjoyed it and agreed that this recipe was a keeper! The tomato paste was good in the sauce even though I was unsure about it.
LKlein Posted: 01/19/10
This was very good. The tomato paste gives it a different flavor, but still very good. I think next time I will try it with out the tomato and see if that makes it better. I also simmered the meat and broth for 30 mins before adding the sour cream mixture. Turned out great the meat was very tender. Will definately add this to my recipe book.
BigBoris Posted: 01/17/10
A very quick, good, lite version of the real thing. For the most flavor, simmer for 10 to 20 minutes after you add the mushrooms. Much better! The kids at every last bite.
RachelRhae Posted: 02/15/10
Made this dish tonight, followed recipe to the tee. Not a hit with my family, most of it went into the garbage disposal. Very tart flavor... one word to describe it...blech.
EllaBella9 Posted: 01/13/11
Pretty good, but needs a few tweaks. First, too much tomato sauce. Second, too much flour. Third, the beef takes longer to cook than 3 minutes (maybe because of flour), so be aware. Also needs some spice--I used a touch of cayenne, and I added garlic to onions. Finally, in the interest of fair warning, I didn't have a nonstick anywhere near big enough for this, so I used a dutch oven. The meat and onions stuck to the bottom badly, but once I added the cream mixture, they came off as brown bits with a little elbow grease.
kate127 Posted: 01/10/12
This is very tasty. I add more sour cream but otherwise follow recipe. If I have leftover quality steak, like filet mignon or ny strip that was cooked rare or medium rare, I just toss it in at end.
neonpink Posted: 04/10/13
Pretty Good! Added extra Worcestershire and less tomato paste.
karenfar Posted: 03/02/13Huntington Beach, CA
REALLY GOOD!! The changes that I made: used 1# beef tenderloin; 3/4 cup chopped onion; 8 ounces cremini mushrooms, sliced; 1/3 cup of flour; and added 1 clove of garlic. I sauteed the onions, mushroom and garlic in butter for a few minutes then added half the broth to the pan. I browned the meat in a separate skillet in butter and gradually added the remaining beef broth to the skillet after the cubes were browned (I didn't want to overcook the meat). I added the meat to the mushrooms pan and cooked for a few minutes to thicken. Then I gradually added the sour cream mixture. The flavor was fabulous and the meat was melt in your mouth tender.