All of the contestants were cooking right up to the final seconds of the challenge. Judge Alex Guarnaschelli nervously pleaded, "Martie, please plate your food!"
SPOILER: Team Alton did a great job, but Martie faced the Producers Challenge this week along with Josh and Nikki. Josh was sent home. The judges recognized Martie's "genuineness" and storytelling skills.
Watch the repeat of the show Wednesday evening. And keep voting for Martie!
And if you can't get enough s'mores, check out the collection of s'mores recipes at Sunset.com.