Vote for The Ultimate Christmas Cookie

Which of these classic Christmas cookie recipes do you consider the ultimate recipe for your holiday treat? Vote now!

  • Caramel-Pretzel Blondies
    Photo: Antonis Achilleos; Styling: Gerri Williams for James Reps

    Caramel-Pretzel Blondies

    Who needs a chocolate brownie when you could have this dreamy blondie loaded with rich, sweet caramel and salty pretzels?

    Vote now for The Ultimate Christmas Cookie.

  • Peppermint-topped Brownies
    Photo: Leigh Beisch

    Peppermint-topped Brownies

    This recipe is guaranteed to please anyone because you can fill the brownie with any flavor from toffee to coconut to white chocolate.

    Vote now for The Ultimate Christmas Cookie.

  • Old-Fashioned Sugar Cookies
    Gooseberry Patch

    Old-Fashioned Sugar Cookies

    Clear the kitchen counters and carve out some time with your kids this holiday season to make these Old-Fashioned Sugar Cookies. You'll have just as much fun cutting the festive shapes as you will enjoying their flavor!

    Vote now for The Ultimate Christmas Cookie.

  • Big Crunchy Sugar Cookies
    Photo: Oxmoor House

    Big Crunchy Sugar Cookies

    Sparkling sugar cookies are holiday classics. These goodies, which earn their name from a coating of coarse sugar, received our Test Kitchens highest rating.

    Vote now for The Ultimate Christmas Cookie.

  • Gingerbread Girls
    Oxmoor House

    Gingerbread Girls

    These firm, crisp, delicious cookies are perfect for topping off a stocking, decorating a mantel, or forming a centerpiece.

    Vote now for The Ultimate Christmas Cookie.

  • Cranberry Thumbprints
    Photo: Annabelle Breakey; Styling: Dan Becker

    Cranberry Thumbprints

    Instead of using jam, fill these bite-sized cookies with your extra Thanksgiving cranberry sauce.

    Vote now for The Ultimate Christmas Cookie.

  • Fruitcake Cookies
    Photo: Lee Harrelson; Styling: Jan Gautro

    Fruitcake Cookies

    Fruitcake's first cousin in cookie form contains all the ingredients you love in fruitcake--candied cherries, chopped pecans, cinnamon, allspice and rum--just in smaller bite-sized portions.  Santa will be very pleased if you leave a plate of these treats out for him when he stops by your house this Christmas Eve.

    Vote now for The Ultimate Christmas Cookie.

  • Cranberry-White Chocolate Cookies

    Cranberry-White Chocolate Cookies

    Fans of classic cookies will love these updated Cranberry-White Chocolate Cookies, accented with dried cranberries and gooey white chocolate.

    Vote now for The Ultimate Christmas Cookie.

advertisement
  1. Enter at least one ingredient